When automating your home lighting, two approaches compete: replacing switches with smart models, or replacing bulbs with smart ones. Here is an honest comparison to help you make the right choice.
Smart Bulbs
Advantages
- Immediate installation: screws in like a regular bulb.
- Colors and ambiances: millions of RGB colors and adjustable white temperatures.
- No electrician needed.
- Great for renters.
Disadvantages
- Wall switch must stay ON: if physically turned off, the bulb loses its connection.
- High cost: $15 to $60 per bulb.
- Dimmer incompatibility: smart bulbs do not work with traditional dimmers.
Smart Switches
Advantages
- Transparent to guests: the wall switch works normally.
- Compatible with all bulbs: keep your regular LED bulbs.
- Lower overall cost: one $40-80 switch controls all bulbs on a circuit.
- Lasting: when you change fixtures, the switch stays.
Disadvantages
- More complex installation: electrical box work required.
- No color control: cannot change bulb color.
Our Recommendation
Renter or want colorful effects? Choose smart bulbs (Philips Hue or LIFX).
Homeowner wanting a discreet, cost-effective solution? Choose smart switches (Lutron Caseta or Shelly).
The ideal solution: combine both — smart switches for living areas, smart bulbs for bedrooms where you want colored ambiances.
Conclusion
Both technologies integrate well with Alexa, Google Home, and Apple HomeKit. The choice depends on your situation, budget, and desired effect.
Find Your Connected Lighting Solution
Whether you choose smart switches or smart bulbs, find the best deals in our smart home catalogue. All brands mentioned in this article are available on Amazon Canada.